iLMS知識社群(Sites)師生部落格(Blogs)朝陽首頁(Homepage)TronClass教學平台Login
Thesis Writing & Publishing I-- Seminar--Mindy's Presentation (1-05-2011)
by 徐碧霙 2011-01-05 15:47:15, Reply(18), Views(1262)
Reply(18)

Comments for Mindy’s presentation

Strength

1.      High confidence as usual!!

2.      Interesting article!!

3.      Eye contact

4.      Perfect explanation

5.      The last picture looks so “delicious”!!

Weakness

1. I couldn’t find your weakness…

Question

I see most of paper use analytical tools of validity, e.g. Cronbach’s alpha, but I have no idea with “KR-21”, do you know why the researcher chosen this tool to examine? And how do you think about Cronbach’s alpha and KR-21, which one you prefer to be your future tool?

Thanks...Alice!! Thanks for your kindness and love you~~
I will reply the questions after all guys post the responces!!
 
u~~
 
Mindy Da-Jie
 

Comments for Mindy’s presentation

Strength

1.      Professional performance.

2.      The slide12 and 15 evoke my thirst of knowledge.

3.      The slide 24 is too hot to find faults with your performance.

4.      Provide more explanation about KR-12 Formula and Think Aloud Report.

Weakness

1.      The slide 25 and 26 are obscure in the handout.

2.      The tense of the slide 21 is not the same.

Question

1. How can you relate this article to your future thesis?

Dear e-pin:
 
Love you the 3rd strength, hehe~~ moreover, it's KR21 not KR12 lah~
same~~I will reply the questions after all classmates responce loh~~
 
u....
 
Mindy Da-Jie
Thanks for KR21. You can see I typed each word, not just copied from you ppt.
 

Comments for Mindy’s presentation

Strength

lYou made a vigorous speech!!

lUse lots of gestures and body language to attract people’ attention.

lYour confidence is the most I want to learn!

Weakness

You are too wonderful to find out your weakness, but here is a
suggestion, maybe next time you can dress with your事業線, I am
looking forward to……..

Question

Do you agree with the result?

Mindy

 

Strength

Clear explanation

Interesting topic

Appropriate speed

Good time controlling

Slide 24 was awesome!!

I can not change my sight from your事業線!!! 

Weakness

Do you know how hard to videotape you, you keep moving and moving…. Haha~ But it’s good for presentation cause you’re trying to explain more details for us. Thank you!  

Question

To explore the further research, how could you define your variables or participants in your future study?

Comments for Mindy’s Presentation

Strength

l   Good speaking pace and body language.

l   Good explanatory and illustrative ppt.

l   Good interpretation of data.

Weakness

l   This paper’s findings are rather limited.

Question

l   Would you say the same outcome may be found if this research was conducted in Taiwan?

Comments for Mindy’s Presentation

Strength

1.          good PPT design

2.          smooth speaking speed

3.          body language

4.          clear presentation

Weakness

1.          steady presentation, no weakness

Question

In your opinion, If it researches in Taiwan, will the result be the same?

Comments for Mindy!!!
 
Strength: 1. Fluent presentation
                2. Interesting topic
                3. Perfect explanation
 
Weakness: 1. Final picture is too sexy, you know, Clement can't stand it.
 
Question:  Except for teaching L2, what kind of thing could  also be 
                 considered in the future investigation? 

Comments for Mindy’s Presentation

Strength

1. You use a lot of pictures in the PPT, very vivid.

2. The methodology part is step by step, design quite well and very organized.

3. Always stay very calm while presenting, cool. 

Weakness

1. I think the findings of this research is foreseeable.
2. Everyone is distracted by your final slide, so we all forgot to ask you questions, haha.

Question

As I know, the IELTS score is from 0~9, but the researcher said the student's mean score is 11, is it correct?

Dear Gary,
 
You are right!
 
All I can remember about Mindy's presentation is  the final slide!
 
 
Teresa
 
 
 

Presenters

Mindy

Strength

Show confident

Provide lots of information about drama

The picture on last slide is SEXY! WOW!

Totally understand the study

Interesting topic

Eye contact

Use gestures

You are my idol~~~!! Haha

Weakness

It’s really hard to find weakness~

Maybe just one, speak a little bit fast

Question

In your opinion, do you think the literature will affect the result? (ex: if the literature is too difficult to understand or read, the students might lose their interests.)

Presenter

                  Mindy               2011/1/5

Strength

It was really professional presentation.

From slide 11 to slide 15, it was really easy to understand two materials of this research.

Weakness

In my opinion, it was really hard to give a comment for weakness.   

Question

Did the author explain why choosing participants who the IELTS score was upper 11 as the sample?

Strength

Eyes contact

Many gestures to help us understanding

Weakness

I can’t find your weakness, your presentation is perfect!

Question

How to avoid bringing characters life to the real world?

Mindy

Strength:

1.      very confident and fluent presentation

2.      slide 7.8.9 very clearly

3.      more explanations at some proper nouns

Weakness:

In slide 2 citation line 5 after (4) should write period not comma.

Question:

Why did you choose this paper to present?

Strength

Present with confidence

Good hand gesture

Look professional

Clear explanation

Weakness

Too hard to think of anything after the last slide….

Question

Is this experiment used in Taiwan as well?

@ Alice,

Actually, I have no idea about the Cronbach’s alpha. If you really want to know what I prefer to use, I would tell you I prefer the easiest one.hehe….

 

@e-ping,

Actually, this paper helps me a lot for my future study. I can use the research design to apply to my thesis.

 

@Joanna,

Yes, I do agree the result. Otherwise, you can figure out more related studies have very similar findings.

 

@Catherine,

I would assign my variables as oral achievement and drama-based teaching method.

 

@Clement,

Yes, I would say that, and you can find there are many related studies have the similar results.

 

@Allen,

You ask the same question as kk, please see the above line.

 

@Peter,

Dear Peter, drama can do many things. In nowadays, many industries integrate drama games into their employee training classes, and so on.

 

@Gary,

Good boy!! You found it!! I have no idea about that as well, because I do not find out any explanation in this paper.

 

@Emily,

Yes, it’s very possible, but as us, drama teachers, often choose suitable materials to our students.

 

@Sabina,

Unfortunately, no!!

@Livia,

Wow….you as a very professional question in drama field. I can explain in CHINESE sometime, and especially FORYOU ONLY!! J

 

@佳秀,

Because I interest in the field, and I currently work with this.

 

@Lulu,

Of course, there is no question that there are many related studies conducted in Taiwan already.

Reply