iLMS知識社群(Sites)師生部落格(Blogs)朝陽首頁(Homepage)TronClass教學平台Login
Research Writing & Publishing II----Proposal Defense Rehearsal-- 王澤
by 徐碧霙 2013-06-19 22:15:20, Reply(10), Views(1165)
 
Reply(10)

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

13%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

14%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

15%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

14%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

13%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

16%

Question:

Why do you choose the participants of freshman and sophomore on slide number 14?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

14%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

14%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

17%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

16%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

16%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

18%

Question:

How are you going to choose sample from the population? 

1.      Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

12%

2.      Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

13%

3.      Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

16%

4.      Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

17%

5.      Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

8%

6.      Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

18%

 

Comments:

Your literature review is very clear.

 

Questions:

On slide 15, your instrument is TOEIC test. Why do you choose the TOEIC test? For example, you can use the TOEFL or GEPT listening part.

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

13%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

12%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

12%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

15%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

15%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

17%

Question:

Why do you choose freshman and sophomore in your study?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree? 13%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field? 13%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data? 15%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem? 13%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data? 12%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional? 18%


Question: Why you choose the freshmen in AFL to be your participants?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

15%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

13%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

48%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

18%

Question: Why would you chose TOEIC rather than other proficiency test as I know it is only related to business English?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

13%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

13%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

15%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

15%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

15%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

17%

You mentioned about TOEIC, which part of TOEIC will you choose? Listening? Reading? Score? Because you did not show any item on PPT, just mentioned you will choose TOEIC.

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

12%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

13%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

12%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

15%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

15%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

16%
 
Pilot test, 30 is too less. Your valid pilot questionnaires are 30. You got to
prepare over 30 to avoid invalid questionnares. Is anxiety only for AFL students?
How about AFL students versus other students from various departments?
 

 

 

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?
13%
2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?
13%
3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?
4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?
5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?
45%
6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?
16%

Question:
Will you want to try another data analysis?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

10%

2.Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

10%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

12%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid applicable to the proposed research problem?

15%

5. Are the statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

12%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

18%

Question: are you going to conduct a TOEIC test? the test takes pretty long time to complete it. are you sure your participants will do it? 

Reply