iLMS知識社群(Sites)師生部落格(Blogs)朝陽首頁(Homepage)TronClass教學平台Login
Research Writing & Publishing II----Proposal Defense Rehearsal-- 俊諺
by 徐碧霙 2013-06-19 22:14:56, Reply(12), Views(1400)
 
Reply(12)

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

10%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

14%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

14%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

13%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

12%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

17%

Question:

How long do you conduct your study on the part of procedure?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

13%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

15%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

15%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

16%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

15%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

18%

Question:

What kind of movies are you going to use on your research? 

1.      Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

11%

2.      Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

12%

3.      Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

15%

4.      Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

15%

5.      Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

6%

6.      Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

16%

 

Comments:

Your presentation is better than last time.

 

Questions:

How long do you execute your research?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

11%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

12%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

12%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

13%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

14%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

16%

Question:

Why do you chose five colleges in your study?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree? 10%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field? 12%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data? 10%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem? 15%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data? 13%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional? 15%


Question: How do you find your participants?

庭欣

How long do you conduct your study on the part of procedure?

Thanks for asking question! I will spend about three months to

Conduct my procedure part.  

佳穎

How long do you execute your research?

Thanks for asking question! I will spend about three months to

Conduct my procedure part.

維真

What kind of movies are you going to use on your research?

Thanks for asking question! I will not focus on movie because of

It’s Longley time, I will choice the Disney channel original movie.   

斐喻

Why do you choose five colleges in your study?

Thanks for asking question! Because I want to conduct every department

freshman student.

思廷

How do you find your participants?

I will prepared questionnaires and sent it to five college department. 

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

10%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

13%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

45%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

16%

Question: There’re many careless mistakes. You need to check it again and again.. Could you explain what your goals are to choose factor analysis and descriptive statistics for? Would it be too simple to qualify for a master degree?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

12%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

12%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

13%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

13%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

14%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

15%

The item of your questionnaire which is reception level, the question of reception level seems few, don’t you worry about validity?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

10%

2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

10%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

10%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?

10%

5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

13%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

14%

Your study is a survey, isn't it? You can survey the degree that people use the multimedia to learn English or other topics. You don't need to limit to BBC. It's mission impossible. BBC is not popular
in Taiwan. You only can hear BBC news from ICRT at 7:00 every morning. But  it could be investigated
how people learning new knowledge or languages by multimedia.
1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?
10%
2. Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?
10%
3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?
4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid data applicable to the proposed research problem?
5. Are the proposed statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?
40%
6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?
15%

Question:
Are you really interested in this research topic?

1. Will the proposed research problem, if successfully carried out, be a significant contribution to this area of knowledge, deserving of an M. S. degree?

9%

2.Does the presentation give reasonable evidence that the student is familiar with significant literature in his/her field?

10%

3. Are the proposed methods adequate to provide valid experimental data?

7%

4. Will the proposed experimental design provide valid applicable to the proposed research problem?

7%

5. Are the statistical procedures adequate to provide valid interpretation of experimental data?

6%

6. Is the oral presentation clear and professional?

14%

Question:is your questionnaire English or Chinese? If it's English, will you translate to Chinese? 

Question:  Could you explain what your goals are to choose factor analysis and descriptive statistics for? Would it be too simple to qualify for a master degree?

Thank you! Radium

A : I understand it seems too simple to get a master degree

, the reason of why I choose factor analysis and descriptive statistics is because I review a proposal from 世新 university, that simple were too large, it including many National University and technology University, then I want to focus on more specific education system.

The item of your questionnaire which is reception level, the question of reception level seems few, don’t you worry about validity?

A : Thank you ! Debbie.

      I also worry about the validity for the item of reception level, so I plan to do a pilot test to test very item’s p value, if some item’s p value haven’t a significant scale, I will add or delete some items.  

 

Are you really interested in this research topic?

A : Thank you ! Tim

The answer is yes! I really interested in this topic. However, I need to consider how can I find participants, and who will be my advisor?  According to several reasons, I just prepare a survey method to be my proposal. But, my proposal still has much exploration when I found advisor.

Is your questionnaire English or Chinese? If it's English, will you translate to Chinese?  

A : Thank you ! Patty

      The questionnaire was written by Chinese and I was adapted from Tien (2009), and I’m consider the possible ability to translate to English. 

Reply